Top email pitching fails

+ remote content job that pays up to $180k/year

Author

Diana Kelly Levey
March 26, 2025

In partnership with

In partnership with

Writers, don’t let your work disappear!

Imagine losing years of articles because a site shut down. What would you do if all your work samples disappeared?

With Authory, that’s a nightmare you’ll never have to face. Authory automatically creates a portfolio that backs up everything you’ve ever written and will write, so your work is always safe.

That’s right: Authory finds and backs up all your past work and saves every new piece you publish, wherever they appear.

Join thousands of writers who already trust Authory to protect their work and never lose a piece again.

Using ChatGPT for “Thought Leadership” Is Like Letting Your Ex Write Your Tinder Bio

They make up stories about who you are.
Miss all the important bits.
Leave you to explain awkward situations.

Fact: Your mind can't be faked. No matter how sophisticated the AI.

Pressmaster.ai doesn't pretend to be you.
It extracts your genius.

One conversation (max 5 minutes).
No prep needed. Just talk. Or ask to start researching.

That single dialogue becomes weeks of authority-building content.
Fact-checked. Engagement-optimized. In YOUR voice.

Actual quote from our user: “I get goose bumps reading this. That sounds exactly like me.”

When you’ve sent thousands of pitches and read hundreds of them as a magazine editor for 10 years, you’ve seen a lot of duds and even sent a few, too.

Here are the top reasons an editor didn’t respond to your pitch. (Spoiler alert: It’s not because you suck.)

1. The Editor Doesn’t Work There Anymore

Magazines and websites are flush with mergers, layoffs, and editors moving around mastheads at a speedy clip.


✅ Do your homework. Google them. Check LinkedIn. Twitter/X. Masthead online if the publication has ‘em.

2. You Pitched the Wrong Section

Pitched beauty to the politics editor? It’s probably why the editor is ignoring you.


✅ Match the pitch to the editor or manager’s beat. Use mastheads, LinkedIn, and bios to confirm.

3. It Went to Spam

They never saw it. This is why the “follow up email” is where most of your business sales happen.


✅ Follow up. Reattach the original pitch. Keep your email and make sure it doesn’t have curses or words that could trigger a spam filter.

4. They Opened It, Then Forgot

They meant to respond. Then, 147 other emails happened.


✅ Follow up with a version of the following:
“Just checking in and wanted to see if you had a chance to review my pitch below. Thanks for considering it.”

Read the rest of the reasons an editor is ghosting you and your freelance pitch in the blog. 👇

Thanks for being a subscriber and reader.

Diana

P.S. Missed last week’s newsletter or a recent post? Check them out here.

P.P.S. Keep scrolling for jobs. ⤵️

Write Article Pitches and Letters of Introduction Editors Want to Read

Tired of spending time writing pitches that go unanswered?

Here are the pitches I wrote that sold to editorial publications like Men’s Journal, Reader’s Digest, Shape, and to brands like Headspace, Fitbit, and more.

Get my bestselling digital download of 24 Pitches That Sold.

"I used your Freelance Pitching template and got approved for an assignment! I sent an article pitch in February, followed up a week later, and I heard back from the editor that I got the assignment!" -Kaneesha Jackson (April 2023)

Customers who've used these freelance article pitch examples and the principles behind them have gone on to write for Glamour, Women's Health, Muscle & Fitness, Well + Good, Food Network, Equinox, Oxygen, and more.

📧 Receive this email from a friend?

(Thanks, friend!)

Subscribe to the weekly freelance writing tips email here.

You’ll get a freelance “pitching tips” PDF resource as a thank-you for subscribing.

What’s Happening in My Business & Life

Add These Fun Emails to Your Inbox

Check out these newsletters to get new educational career content, writing inspiration, and jobs in your email.

Creator Spotlight: Wondering how to build an audience and monetize it? Get social media and content creation tips in this newsletter along with “deep dives” on Fridays.

lowercase b2b: This newsletter shows you how to make B2B writing more fun and enjoyable for all parties involved.

Study Hall Sampler: Subscribe to this email for even more freelance job opportunities in your inbox, as well as recent journalism and industry news.

Big Desk Energy: If you’re always chasing startup trends and want to know what’s happening in that culture like I am, you’ll enjoy this newsletter share insights each week.

Freelance Jobs, Contract Jobs, or Remote Jobs I Found

(These were active and available within a few days of this newsletter going out. I have no connection with them.)

Good luck! Let me know if you get any of these jobs. I’d love to share your success in a future newsletter.

Reply

or to participate.